DIY Marshmallow Peeps for Dogs | Easter Dog Treats

DIY Dog Treats time! Easter is coming, and we thought it would be fun to try something new!  Peeps for dogs!  That’s right, we are making marshmallow Peeps for dogs!

DIY Marshmallow Peeps for Dogs
DIY marshmallow Peeps for dogs

  • 3 Tbls Plain, Unflavored Gelatin
  • 1 cup Honey
  • 1 cup water (split in two)
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 1/4 tsp Salt
  • Coconut flour for dusting


I used my Kitchen Aid mixer for this, but you can use a hand mixer.  It will just take a bit longer.  First, take your Gelatin, and 1/2 cup of water and put it into your mixing bowl. Stir it slightly with a spoon.  While that sits, take a saucepan and put your honey, 1/2 cup of water, vanilla extract and salt into the pan.  Heat on a medium to high heat, mixing constantly, until you bring the temperature of the mixture to 240 degrees Fahrenheit. This will take around 6 – 10 minutes.

Once your mixture reaches the right temperature, remove the pan, slowly and carefully pour it into you mixer while on the low setting (I used the whisk attachment for my mixer)  Once it’s all poured in, slowly increase the speed of your mixer being careful not to splash the hot mix all over.  Once your mixer is on high, let it mix for around 10 minutes, or until you have a nice fluffy consistency.

While the fluff is mixing spray your pans lightly with Bakers Joy. I am using a Peeps silicon mold pan, and an 8×8 cake pan.   This will stop the marshmallow peeps from sticking once they are set.  After the mix is fluffy, you can spoon it into a pastry bag to make filling your mold easier.  Whatever is left, you can pour into an 8×8 pan and cut into cubed marshmallows later.

After you have filled your pans, let them sit for at least 4 – 5 hours so that the mixture can properly set.  Now you can remove the Marshmallow Peeps from the mold.  They will still be sticky, so take a cutting board, and dust it with coconut flour.  Lightly tap the Marshmallow Peeps in the flour to help coat the sticky parts, and that’s it!  You have now created Marshmallow Peeps for dogs!  And yes, you can eat them too!

DIY marshmallow Peeps for dogs

Taste test time

Now it’s time for the dogs to taste and enjoy these Marshmallow Peeps for dogs!  We hope they like them as much as ours did!
DIY marshmallow Peeps for dogs

Don’t forget to share this with your friends so they can make it with their dogs! Let us know in the comments what type of treat you want us to try making next time! Happy Easter everyone!

Here are the affiliate links to some of the things we used in the video.
Peeps Silicone Mold:
Digital Thermometer:
Coconut Flour:
Kitchen Aid Mixer: 

MORE Treat videos:
* Please note that I’m neither a vet nor an animal nutritionist, so it’s advisable to consult with your own authority when trying new foods, and also to ensure that your dog’s home cooked diet is balanced & includes all of the nutrients that are necessary for your dog’s health. As with ALL treats, feed in moderation, and don’t feed anything to your dogs that you don’t feel comfortable feeding them.  These are treats, not meal replacements.


DIY marshmallow Peeps for dogs
DIY Marshmallow Peeps for Dogs! The perfect Easter Treat!

Share Us: